New York Yankees betting record
Every graded pick we've made on New York Yankees games since 2021 — wins and losses, straight from the public record.
28–21
record
+1.15u
units
+2.3%
yield · 49 picks
6
seasons since 2021
We've graded 49 single-game picks involving New York Yankees since 2021: 28–21, +1.15u, a +2.3% yield.
Backing New York Yankees directly (moneyline and run line): 24 picks, 16–8, +4.68u.
Totals in their games: 21 picks, 9–12, −4.99u.
New York Yankees team totals: 4 picks, 3–1, +1.46u.
Among the 30 MLB teams with a record page, that's #21 by units and #10 by number of picks. Our full MLB record: 775–552, +110.85u (+8.3%).
By price: at odds below 2.00, 24–21 (−3.31u); at 2.00 or longer, 4–0 (+4.46u).
Longest winning run: 7. Longest losing run: 4.
Record by bet type
| Type | Picks | Record | Units | Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Backing them | 24 | 16–8 | +4.68u | +19.5% |
| Game totals | 21 | 9–12 | −4.99u | −23.8% |
| Team totals | 4 | 3–1 | +1.46u | +36.5% |
Record by season
| Season | Picks | Record | Units | Yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | 14 | 10–4 | +4.20u | +30.0% |
| 2025 | 10 | 5–5 | −1.85u | −18.5% |
| 2024 | 12 | 8–4 | +3.08u | +25.7% |
| 2023 | 4 | 2–2 | −0.48u | −12.0% |
| 2022 | 5 | 2–3 | −1.46u | −29.2% |
| 2021 | 4 | 1–3 | −2.34u | −58.5% |
Every New York Yankees pick
| Date | Type | Pick | Odds | Result | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-09-10 | Side | New York Yankees -1.5 in Colorado Rockies @ New York Yankees | 1.72 | WIN | +0.72u |
| 2026-09-08 | Side | New York Yankees -1.5 in Colorado Rockies @ New York Yankees | 1.67 | WIN | +0.67u |
| 2026-09-02 | Side | New York Yankees -1.5 in New York Yankees @ Los Angeles Angels | 2.05 | WIN | +1.05u |
| 2026-08-21 | Side | New York Yankees -1.5 in Toronto Blue Jays @ New York Yankees | 2.01 | WIN | +1.01u |
| 2026-08-19 | Game total | OVER 9.5 Runs in New York Yankees @ Baltimore Orioles | 1.96 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2026-08-14 | Side | New York Yankees ML in New York Yankees @ Toronto Blue Jays | 1.71 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2026-07-31 | Game total | Over 9.0 in New York Yankees @ Chicago Cubs | 1.82 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2026-07-11 | Game total | Under 9.5 in New York Yankees @ Washington Nationals | 1.72 | WIN | +0.72u |
| 2026-06-28 | Game total | Under 8.5 in New York Yankees @ Boston Red Sox | 1.71 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2026-06-13 | Side | New York Yankees Money Line in New York Yankees @ Toronto Blue Jays | 1.80 | WIN | +0.80u |
| 2026-05-31 | Team total | New York Yankees Team Total Over 5.5 Runs in New York Yankees @ Athletics | 1.95 | WIN | +0.95u |
| 2026-05-15 | Game total | UNDER 8.0 in New York Yankees @ New York Mets | 1.76 | WIN | +0.76u |
| 2026-05-11 | Side | New York Yankees Money Line in New York Yankees @ Baltimore Orioles | 1.76 | WIN | +0.76u |
| 2026-05-09 | Game total | Under 8.0 Runs in New York Yankees @ Milwaukee Brewers | 1.76 | WIN | +0.76u |
| 2025-08-23 | Game total | Over 8.0 Runs in Boston Red Sox vs. New York Yankees | 1.80 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2025-07-08 | Game total | Under 9.0 Runs in Seattle Mariners vs. New York Yankees | 1.71 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2025-07-05 | Side | Yankees to Win in New York Yankees vs. New York Mets | 1.66 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2025-06-24 | Side | Yankees to Win in New York Yankees vs. Cincinnati Reds | 1.83 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2025-06-05 | Side | Yankees −1.5 Run line in Cleveland Guardians vs. New York Yankees | 1.36 | WIN | +0.36u |
| 2025-05-23 | Game total | Over 11.5 runs in New York Yankees vs. Colorado Rockies | 1.66 | WIN | +0.66u |
| 2025-05-18 | Side | Yankees to Win in Mets vs. Yankees | 1.60 | WIN | +0.60u |
| 2025-05-16 | Game total | Under 9.0 Total in Mets vs. Yankees | 1.87 | WIN | +0.87u |
| 2025-04-20 | Side | Yankees to Win in Yankees vs. Rays | 1.66 | WIN | +0.66u |
| 2025-04-19 | Game total | Under 9.5 Total Runs in Yankees vs. Rays | 1.74 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2024-08-12 | Side | NY Yankees -1.5 run line | 1.67 | LOSS | −1.00u |
SHOW 24 OLDER PICKS
| Date | Type | Pick | Odds | Result | Units |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024-08-04 | Game total | Over 9.0 runs in Blue Jays at Yankees | 1.83 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2024-08-03 | Game total | Over 8.5 runs in Blue Jays at Yankees | 1.71 | WIN | +0.71u |
| 2024-06-21 | Side | NY Yankees to win | 1.90 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2024-06-05 | Side | NY Yankees -1.5 run line | 2.20 | WIN | +1.20u |
| 2024-06-04 | Side | NY Yankees -1.5 run line | 2.20 | WIN | +1.20u |
| 2024-06-02 | Game total | Over 7.5 runs in Yankees at Giants | 1.80 | WIN | +0.80u |
| 2024-05-30 | Team total | NY Yankees over 4.5 runs | 1.80 | WIN | +0.80u |
| 2024-05-20 | Team total | NY Yankees over 3.5 runs | 1.71 | WIN | +0.71u |
| 2024-05-08 | Side | NY Yankees to win | 1.71 | WIN | +0.71u |
| 2024-04-17 | Side | NY Yankees to win | 1.95 | WIN | +0.95u |
| 2024-04-05 | Side | NY Yankees to win | 1.66 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2023-07-30 | Game total | Over 9.0 runs in Yankees at Orioles | 1.90 | WIN | +0.90u |
| 2023-07-15 | Side | NY Yankees to win | 1.62 | WIN | +0.62u |
| 2023-06-25 | Game total | Under 7.5 runs in Rangers at Yankees | 1.87 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2023-05-25 | Game total | Over 9.0 runs in Orioles at Yankees | 1.87 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2022-08-29 | Game total | Over 8.0 runs in Yankees at Angels | 1.90 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2022-08-18 | Game total | Over 8.0 runs in Blue Jays at Yankees | 1.83 | WIN | +0.83u |
| 2022-07-12 | Game total | Over 8.0 runs in Reds at Yankees | 1.87 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2022-06-04 | Side | NY Yankees -1.5 run line | 1.71 | WIN | +0.71u |
| 2022-05-14 | Team total | NY Yankees over 4.5 runs | 1.76 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2021-09-01 | Side | NY Yankees -1.5 run line | 1.66 | WIN | +0.66u |
| 2021-08-04 | Game total | Under 10.runs in Orioles at Yankees | 1.76 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2021-05-30 | Side | NY Yankees to win | 1.68 | LOSS | −1.00u |
| 2021-04-29 | Side | NY Yankees -1.5 run line | 1.86 | LOSS | −1.00u |
42 combined bets naming New York Yankees — not counted in the record above
- 2025-05-02Yankees and Giants to Win.WIN +1.00u
- 2024-08-27Tigers and Yankees to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2024-08-25Cubs to win and Over 6.5 runs in Rockies at YankeesLOSS −1.00u
- 2024-08-23Yankees and Braves to winWIN +0.86u
- 2024-08-21Over 6.5 Runs in Guardians at Yankees and Royals to winWIN +1.22u
- 2024-07-02Yankees and Braves to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2024-05-18Yankees and Royals to winWIN +1.04u
- 2024-04-09Yankees and Dodgers to winWIN +1.29u
- 2023-08-19Under 10.0 runs in Red Sox at Yankees and Cubs to winWIN +1.18u
- 2023-07-23Padres to win and Over 7.0 runs in Royals at YankeesLOSS −1.00u
- 2023-07-22Yankees to win and Cardinals over 2.5 runsWIN +0.73u
- 2023-07-16Orioles and Yankees to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2023-04-22Yankees and Twins to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-09-13Over 6.5 runs in Yankees at Red Sox and Cardinals to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-09-05Yankees and Angels to winWIN +1.42u
- 2022-07-31Blue Jays to win and Yankees over 3.5 runsWIN +0.71u
- 2022-07-30Yankees and Astros to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-07-29Yankees and Astros to winWIN +0.99u
- 2022-07-28Yankees to win and Guardians over 2.5 runsLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-07-26Blue Jays to win and Over 6.0 runs in Yankees at MetsWIN +0.92u
- 2022-07-13Yankees over 3.5 runs and Rays to winWIN +0.95u
- 2022-07-08Over 7.5 runs in Yankees at Red Sox and Over 6.5 runs in Pirates at BrewersWIN +0.93u
- 2022-07-03Brewers to win and Yankees over 2.5 runsLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-07-02Yankees (Game 2) Over 2.5 and Red Sox over 3.5 runsLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-07-02Yankees (Game 1) and Brewers over 3.5 runsWIN +0.71u
- 2022-06-27Yankees to win and Over 7.0 runs in Red Sox at Blue JaysWIN +0.72u
- 2022-06-26Over 6.5 runs in Astros at Yankees and Rays F5WIN +0.85u
- 2022-06-10Yankees and Padres to winWIN +0.92u
- 2022-06-09Braves and Yankees to winWIN +1.02u
- 2022-06-03Yankees and Blue Jays to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-05-23Yankees and Dodgers to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-05-18Marlins and Yankees +0.5 first 5 inningsWIN +0.73u
- 2022-05-17Yankees to win and Angels over 2.5 runsWIN +0.86u
- 2022-05-09Yankees and Dodgers to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2022-04-30Yankees +0.5 F5 and Giants to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2021-09-22Phillies and Yankees to winWIN +0.85u
- 2021-09-21Yankees to wind and Jays +2.5 run lineWIN +0.76u
- 2021-08-02Over 8.0 in Orioles at Yankees and Over 7.0 in Phillies at NationalsWIN +0.38u
- 2021-06-22White Sox and Yankees to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2021-05-28Yankees and Dodgers to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2021-05-17NY Yankees and San Diego Padres to winLOSS −1.00u
- 2021-05-14NY Yankees to win and Under 10.0 runs in Indians at MarinersWIN +0.58u
Weekly recaps with New York Yankees picks
Counts single-game picks where New York Yankees is named: picks backing them, their team totals, and game totals or props in their games. Combined bets are listed but not counted. A game total counts for both teams, so team pages overlap and don't add up to the overall record. Graded picks only, pushes excluded. Methodology · Full record. Not affiliated with New York Yankees or the MLB.
Free Telegram channel
Get the next one before the game.
Some of my picks go out free on Telegram before kickoff, along with the pick'em game and the weekly record card. Premium gets every pick. All of them end up on the public record, wins and losses.